Field note · 15 November 2026
Why the ratio, not the compound, is the product
Four examples where the same chemistry at a different ratio is a different product for a different insect — and what that means for a purchase order.
Buyers often ask for “the pheromone for species X”. For a large part of this catalogue the honest answer is a ratio, not a compound, and the difference is not academic.
Ips bark beetles
Ipsdienol and ipsenol in different proportions, plus a host monoterpene, define blends for different Ips species. A blend tuned for I. typographus under-collects I. pini, and the resulting map shows a population difference that is really a formulation difference. Programmes that need species-level data run separate blends and separate traps; programmes that only need “is there an outbreak” can use a compromise lure and say so.
Choristoneura budworms
(E)- and (Z)-11-tetradecenal in different proportions, with the corresponding alcohols. The geometry is the species message, which is why a “budworm lure” is a category error and why the isomer distribution on the certificate matters more than the assay.
Ostrinia corn borers
The textbook case: the Z and E strains of European corn borer respond to opposite blends of the same two acetates. One species, two lures, and a programme that runs only one of them reports half the population with confidence.
Leafrollers
Obliquebanded leafroller is a four-component blend. Change the acetate proportion and it stops being an OBLR lure; add a congener’s component and you begin catching the congener instead. There is no single-compound version of this lure that works as well.
What this means when ordering
- Specify the ratio, not just the components. “Ips lure” is not a specification.
- Ask for the ratio to appear on the certificate, per lot.
- Do not change supplier mid-series without comparing blends on paper first — the paper is where the difference will be visible.
- If a blend is proprietary, ask what it was validated against. A blend without a reference is a blend without a claim.
The one-line version
In this catalogue, the compound is the ingredient and the ratio is the product. Price comparisons that ignore the second number are comparing different things.