Field note · 15 November 2026
Writing a lure specification that survives a tender
Eight clauses turn a pheromone requirement into something two suppliers can be compared against — and something an auditor can check three years later.
Most tender failures in this category are not commercial. They are specifications that describe a material in words loose enough for two suppliers to answer differently and both be technically compliant. The fix is eight clauses.
The eight clauses
- Compound and CAS number. The name alone is ambiguous; several entries in every catalogue share a name and differ by geometry.
- Isomeric composition. (E)/(Z) ratio, or “defined mixture” with proportions. This is the clause that decides whether the lure behaves.
- Assay basis. GC area percent or internal standard — the two are not interchangeable, and a 2% difference in figure can be entirely a difference in method.
- Dispenser type and loading. Septum, vial, membrane; mass per dispenser; and the intended replacement interval.
- Release rate, with conditions. A rate without a temperature is a number without a meaning.
- Documentation set. Certificate of analysis, GC trace, SDS in the required language, isomer statement where relevant.
- Traceability. Lot number on certificate, packing list and delivery note; retained sample held for a stated period.
- Acceptance test. What happens if a delivered lot is disputed: which method, which laboratory, which sample.
Equivalence, if you must allow it
“Or equivalent” without a test is an invitation to substitute. If equivalence is acceptable, define it: same CAS, isomer within a stated tolerance, assay within a stated tolerance, identical documentation set, and a sample tested against the reference before acceptance. Otherwise delete the phrase.
What to leave out
Brand names (they exclude competitors and lock you in), vague performance promises (“highly attractive”), and unit prices quoted against unmatched pack sizes. A price per kilogram of active is not comparable between a 95% and a 98% material, and it says nothing about the dispenser the programme is actually buying.
A clause that saves arguments later
Add: “Supplier to state the isomeric composition of each component on the certificate of analysis for each lot, and to retain a sample for 24 months.” It costs nothing at tender, and it is the difference between a disputed catch series being resolvable and being an anecdote.
Evaluating the bids
Score on the eight clauses first and price second. A bid that answers six clauses is not cheaper — it is incomplete, and the missing two will be discovered in the field, where they cost a season rather than a line item.